The current study explored the relationship between the Dark Triad (DT) traits and two comic style markers, that is, irony and sarcasm. We hypothesized that psychopathy, narcissism, and Machiavellianism would be correlated with irony and sarcasm. However, to investigate the unique effects of each DT trait on both comic styles, we fit a bifactor model of the Dirty Dozen Scale (DDS), which enabled us to separate the general factor of dark personality from its specific aspects, that is psychopathy, narcissism (which we also measured using the Narcissistic Admiration and Rivalry Questionnaire Short Scale, NARQ-S), and Machiavellianism. Two hundred and eighty-five participants completed three questionnaires: the Comic Style Markers (CSM), NARQ-S, and the DDS. Irony and sarcasm use were positively correlated with the dark personality general factor (DDS) and both subscales of the NARQ-S. CSM irony was also negatively correlated with age, while CSM sarcasm was positively correlated with DDS psychopathy. For CSM irony, age was a negative predictor, while the dark personality general factor and the NARQ-S rivalry subscale were positive predictors. Finally, for CSM sarcasm, the dark personality general factor as well as the specific factor of DDS psychopathy and the NARQ-S rivalry subscale were all positive predictors.